People talk
Our Guestbook
“ This place has great food wonderful owners Hope was amazing she provided amazing customer service along with going the extra mile and as a result we adopted a new abandoned toy It was a brontosaurus. Put a smile on my face awesome place to eat and has a particular hometown feel the overall experience was above and beyond.. no question we will return!! ”
“ We ordered two large pizzas and lg bread sticks. Our pizzas consisted of toppings, almost no sauce, and barely any cheese it was like eating bread with just toppings and the "cheese"bread sticks if you can even call them that had the same problem it's pretty much just regular bread sticks. Very disappointed cause they used to have better service and I loved taking the family to dine in but it's gone kinda downhill. This is the second time this has happened and the third time they they got my order completely wrong. It sucks when you have kids and they're ready for dinner but nope we have to take our order back and kids have to wait another 45 min to have dinner. You'd think on an order for about 60 they'd try to at least make an effort. This is ridiculous! ”
“ Cheese Pizza with ranch sauce is the best! They have the best service to match it. ”
“ I've been trying to try this place for months and finally made it. This will be my new go to place. Pizza was excellent. ”
“ Riding through the state and I had a taste for pizza. I searched different pizza places and decided to try something local. I had a slight hiccup with what I was charged but it was rectified quickly. I ordered a small salad and a medium pizza topped with mushrooms, ground beef, jalapeno peppers and olives. I'm eating right now and I would never exaggerate about the taste. This pizza is the bomb. So so good and baked perfectly. Shout out to Payette, ID. They have a hidden gem ”
“ Great vibes, great pizza! Thanks for letting us play a couple songs!!! - A Brother’s Fountain ”
“ Loved being here! Great pizza, friendly staff, fun games, and they had great taste in music! ”
“ Great price on pizza ,wings,the kids love the bread sticks,love the arcade games for the kids ,great and respectful staff,fast with the orders,great place to eat at, highly recommended if u around the are ”
Menu
Plain Cheese & Sauce Pizza
Cheesesteak Wrap
Roast Beef Club
Tuna Club
Chicken Salad Club
About
Keystone Pizza
Welcome to Keystone Pizza, a beloved spot nestled in the heart of Payette, Idaho, at 17 S Main St. This local gem has carved out a niche for itself in the competitive food scene with its delectable pizzas and a strong sense of community.
Keystone Pizza offers a unique variety of options, from the White Cheese Pizza laden with fresh garlic and provolone cheese, to their inventive Upside Down Pizza, which flips the traditional style on its head by placing the cheese beneath the sauce. If you're a fan of the classics, you can also indulge in their Plain Cheese & Sauce Pizza or build your own masterpiece tailored to your cravings. For those seeking a taste of the tropics, their Hawaiian Style Pizza comes topped with savory bacon, sweet pineapple, and ham, making it a must-try!
The menu extends beyond pizzas to a variety of irresistible appetizers, such as the Keystone Sampler, featuring an ensemble of mozzarella sticks, jalapeno poppers, and more, perfect for sharing with friends or as a satisfying solo snack. The Greek Fries drizzled with feta cheese add a delightful twist that leaves your taste buds dancing.
As a food reviewer, I was particularly charmed by the welcoming ambiance and impressive customer service reported by patrons. According to Albert Bradley, the owners are exceptional, creating a homey feel where good food and great company come together. This sentiment is echoed by Nikki Rieb, who raved about their Cheese Pizza paired perfectly with ranch sauce, noting the outstanding service.
However, not every review paints a perfect picture. Some guests, like Adriana Gonzalez, expressed disappointment with consistency in the quality and service, which are crucial for family experiences. It's important for Keystone Pizza to address these concerns to maintain their place as a community favorite.
All in all, Keystone Pizza stands out as a delightful spot with the potential to attract both local and visiting pizza enthusiasts. Whether you're craving a classic or something a little different, the offerings here are sure to please. As I look forward to more visits, Keystone Pizza is set to be a memorable culinary stop in Payette, Idaho.
Book a table